AI assists adversarial collaboration in debate on minority salience
Barbara A. Mellers, Leo Yuan, Yubo Zhou, Isabelle Mauboussin, Eyana C. Lao, Bea Corio, Ville Satopää, Lyle Ungar 等 18 位
University of Pennsylvania INSEAD New College of Florida New York University
阅读操作
确认中在文库中上传 PDF 后可生成中文音频讲解。
摘要与影响
The advancement of science depends on rigorous tests of competing hypotheses, yet many disputes are left unresolved. Adversarial collaboration-where opposing scientists jointly design decisive tests-is one proposed solution. We examine whether large language models (LLMs) can play a role by organizing information, structuring the debate and generating candidate experimental designs. This article reports an AI-assisted adversarial collaboration designed to resolve a debate in PNAS on minority salience-an overestimation of the percentage of minority faces in a visual display. The debate focused on whether there would be further overestimation when minorities in the displays were the same minorities in participants' communities (or social environments). Using LLMs to extract and organize competing propositions, we identified central disagreements and generated initial experimental designs to test claims. Human collaborators refined the designs and created two preregistered experiments that factorially manipulated the ethnicity of minority faces and the ethnicity of participants' communities. Data showed that people exaggerated the percentage of minorities in facial displays. Furthermore, overestimation was even greater when minorities in facial displays were also minorities in participants' communities. When the two camps of researchers saw the results, their confidence in key hypotheses converged. We do not experimentally test AI-assisted adversarial collaboration relative to traditional adversarial collaboration or other forms of dispute resolution. Rather, our study illustrates how an AI tool can be used with adversarial collaboration to formalize claims, structure disagreements, lower barriers to collaboration, and serve as an impartial observer to strengthen perceptions of fairness.
逐年被引趋势
暂无年度引用数据
关键指标
同类平均 = 1
同领域 · 同年份 · 同类型
Google Scholar 与 OpenAlex 的被引统计范围不同,数值存在差异属正常。
AI 辅助阅读
依据:摘要
可就本文提问;依据不足时会说明。
学术脉络
学科主题
计算机 / AIEthics and Social Impacts of AI
Face Recognition and Perception · Social and Intergroup Psychology