Expert recommendations on the assessment of wall shear stress in human coronary arteries: existing methodologies, technical considerations, and clinical applications
Frank J H Gijsen, Yuki Katagiri, Peter Barlis, Christos V. Bourantas, Carlos Adolfo Collet, Ahmet Umit Coskun, Joost Daemen, Jouke Dijkstra 等 29 位
Erasmus MC Amsterdam University Medical Centers University of Amsterdam The University of Melbourne
阅读操作
确认中在文库中上传 PDF 后可生成中文音频讲解。
摘要与影响
When blood flows through an artery, it exerts forces on the vessel wall (Figure 1). The perpendicular component of that force vector is associated with blood pressure, leading to deformation of the cells in the vessel wall. The tangential component of that force vector is much smaller and can be sensed by the endothelium through a shearing deformation (‘shearing force’). Each force has a magnitude and direction, and for the shear force, they both change during the cardiac cycle. If we normalize this tangential force vector by the area, we obtain the wall shear stress (unit: 1 Pa = 10 dynes/cm2). Wall shear stress has a major impact on endothelial function and therefore plays a key role in atherosclerotic disease development and in long-term evolution and healing of vessels treated by intravascular devices. Wall shear stress is orders of magnitude smaller than other mechanical stresses affecting the coronary arteries, such as tensile stress or compressive stress and exerts its powerful vascular effects not by a mechanical impact on vascular structure per se, but uniquely by triggering biologic signalling. The biological impact of wall shear stress will be reviewed briefly in ‘The biological relevance of wall shear stress’ section. A schematic representation of the forces the vessel wall is exposed to. The red arrow is the normal force component, associated with blood pressure, and the green arrow is the tangential component force, associated with wall shear stress. Note that the size of the arrows does not represents the magnitude of the forces, only the direction. Since wall shear stress in coronary arteries cannot be measured directly, we need to compute through solving the equations that describe the motion of fluids: the Navier–Stokes equations. The most widely used method to solve these complex equations is called computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Given the appropriate input data, the velocity and pressure distribution can be computed with CFD and the local wall shear stress distribution in coronary arteries can be derived. CFD in the coronary arteries has recently gained increased clinical interest with the advent of computed tomography coronary angiography-derived fractional flow reserve (FFRCT) technology for non-invasive assessment of coronary stenosis severity. The solution of the full Navier–Stokes equations provides complete velocity and pressure information at any location in the coronary artery at any point in time. Solving these equations can be time consuming and computationally expensive and therefore many studies make use of simplified equations, many of them building on the seminal work of Young and Tsai and Gould.1–3 Reductional approaches can be useful for specialized applications, but they often rely on assumptions that do not hold for coronary artery flow. A recent series of applications produce predictions of bulk pressure drops in stenosed arteries under hyperaemia to determine the FFR. Especially under elevated flow conditions, the non-linear nature of the Navier–Stokes equations becomes dominant, often leading to an underestimation of the pressure drop when applying reduced models. The aim of this manuscript is to provide guidelines for appropriate use of CFD to obtain reproducible and reliable wall shear stress maps in native and instrumented human coronary arteries. The outcome of CFD heavily depends on the quality of the input data, which include vessel geometrical data, proper boundary conditions, and material models. Available methodologies to reconstruct coronary artery anatomy are discussed in ‘Imaging coronary arteries: a brief review’ section. Computational procedures implemented to simulate blood flow in native coronary arteries are presented in ‘Wall shear stress in native arteries’ section. The effect of including different geometrical scales due to the presence of stent struts in instrumented arteries is highlighted in ‘Wall shear stress in stents’ section. The clinical implications are discussed in ‘Clinical applications’ section, and concluding remarks are presented in ‘Concluding remarks’ section. Wall shear stress is sensed by endothelial cells via multiple wall shear stress-responsive cell components, which (de)activate intra-cellular pathways leading to regulation of gene and protein expression. This force-induced regulatory process plays a continuous role in the development, growth, remodelling, and maintenance of the vascular system (Table 1 and Figure 2). Generally, endothelial cells exposed to high, unidirectional wall shear stress assume a quiescent state, while endothelial cells exposed to low and/or directional varying wall shear stress are activated, displaying a pro-inflammatory state.4 There is also an important interplay between wall shear stress and pro-inflammatory cytokines such as tumour necrosis factor (TNF) and interleukin (IL)-1β. These cytokines function as central drivers of arterial inflammation by inducing endothelial expression of adhesion protein and chemokines that co-operate to capture leukocytes from the blood stream to the vessel wall. High shear stress reduces the ability of TNF or IL-1β to activate EC whereas low shear stress them for pro-inflammatory the that of IL-1β to reduced in with a highlighted the of IL-1β in The the or effects of wall shear stress are by wall shear stress-responsive The and are by wall shear stress and to be in the regulation of of wall shear the and are by low and/or wall shear stress and pro-inflammatory The wall shear stress pathways also endothelial function and vessel This regulation of vascular via of and but also long-term including vascular remodelling, and to This provides a brief of of the most important and pathways that wall shear stress to and a of these and other and role in of endothelial the is to other A schematic of of the that are in development and and these are to wall shear stress. low wall shear stress are by the endothelium through the expression of adhesion cells which can and are the for the development of the of the but this process the wall shear the is exposed to High wall shear stress will be at the and the of the while in the low wall shear stress will be by elevated of flow. is effect of wall shear stress on shear stress does endothelial leading to in the wall shear stress of shear stress and its effects on Pa is often used to shear whereas Pa is the most used to simulate often high, arterial shear stress. with a shear stress of Pa measured in the disease of the and in human coronary arteries, wall shear stress to be atherosclerotic human arteries, shear stress can with in is elevated at the stenosis of Pa in Pa is used to elevated shear stress in it be that low shear stress is associated with in human coronary The effect of shear stress on and are reviewed in and effect on in vessels are reviewed in and not material of shear stress and its effects on Pa is often used to shear whereas Pa is the most used to simulate often high, arterial shear stress. with a shear stress of Pa measured in the disease of the and in human coronary arteries, wall shear stress to be atherosclerotic human arteries, shear stress can with in is elevated at the stenosis of Pa in Pa is used to elevated shear stress in it be that low shear stress is associated with in human coronary The effect of shear stress on and are reviewed in and effect on in vessels are reviewed in and not material of the pathways that and in arteries a key role in the development of coronary artery disease and to The low and/or wall shear of the endothelium at the of arteries, of of at such as and or from these with adhesion vascular cell adhesion and protein of and on the endothelial The the they that and them the arterial wall and leading to atherosclerotic the of the the artery will to and the wall shear stress and the pro-inflammatory of the endothelium the this low wall shear stress to to to and of arteries with are exposed to flow and wall shear stress which and in via of and which and the of the both and low wall shear stresses to a in of and a that is exposed to wall shear low in or in while a that is exposed to increased and in wall shear both wall shear stress leading to of coronary with a low wall shear stress has to a in reduced and increased of coronary are by a a in which the to be by endothelial is the than for has that both and low wall shear stress can be of endothelial to on atherosclerotic these endothelial and of endothelial with the are to be in endothelial and to be by wall shear stress in endothelial to be as on the of a role for low and/or wall shear These that biological in to wall shear a role in this has that wall shear stress also plays an important role in local artery and wall shear stress If the stent is and the local wall shear stress will be or If the artery is or by the the wall shear stress that the disease be the presence of stent on and can to the of wall shear stress in between the stent the local at the and of the shear stress wall shear stress on the of the struts and The as they the wall shear stress the the in and wall shear stress the struts can the to factor that endothelial in these The wall shear stress on of the struts in while the wall shear stress in the of the struts reduces endothelial and cell the these presented wall shear stress has associated with development and biological are reviewed in and in human coronary arteries which can in the need for of a and of the coronary arteries are computed tomography and intravascular including intravascular tomography and other are under development and applications in coronary and of the assessment of the of the coronary arteries is a of the arterial with a size of information from or at the during the cardiac a of the coronary artery can be to of and the of these in the of coronary wall shear stress as studies a between the wall shear stress in and from intravascular while a the other is on its in which are to the such as which is as the of pressure to the to the The of CFD in from multiple or in the has in with tomography of the coronary and it can be used to distribution in coronary and the effect of the local forces in these These at a of a and reliable of the of the that are to an impact on the wall shear stress and the between local forces and recent studies used to wall shear and that computational in can provide useful information and that will atherosclerotic disease its in the of has also to reconstruct for CFD but its is for coronary arteries therefore this is not for coronary artery the of and and to reconstruct of the coronary arteries of or and intravascular has These from the of the in and of the vessel wall and its on of or and or the the of the or the from the of the or the of the the or the and the of the or the and the of the of the with the on the or the use of in both or and or to the of the or (Figure to computed tomography and intravascular of from computed tomography computed tomography are to the and that are in intravascular tomography are the intravascular are as to obtain the The intravascular are perpendicular to the by computed tomography to reconstruct the coronary artery anatomy that is in the that used to reconstruct coronary This with its assessment of and and has the role of wall shear stress on atherosclerotic A of is its to and its low that do not of to and ability to has that of the is that is to associated with that are by such as the and in to of the struts in and as it has in in can flow and in the between the of is to and the are discussed in in and section. to the effect of wall shear stress on and in coronary artery of and coronary or to the of the local wall shear stress on the of and or to the of the local wall shear stress distribution in a the of and or coronary and in and vessel wall anatomy but it can be to the wall shear stress and on evolution in intravascular is not an are not for assessment of the wall shear stress Wall shear stress the coronary artery can be by solving the equations the motion of the arteries and blood flow with boundary The system as a represents a complex it that full including the motion of the of the of the coronary artery only for in the most widely used the wall shear stress in a recent the is to this section, we will on wall shear stress in coronary arteries with will be for of the artery the boundary and material of blood to the CFD the and for wall shear stress for Wall shear stress in native arteries and Wall shear stress in are in material The of blood flow in the coronary arteries are on the the presence of and as as the nature of the flow (Figure These geometrical and will such as flow and/or which will a role in the wall shear stress dynamics at the of interest The of the of the coronary arteries for a development of the which is for an representation of the wall shear stress and it is from or be to the of both and coronary artery multiple and flow in the presence of the due to varying such as and the presence of arterial has a major impact on wall shear stress is a effect of on wall shear stress. coronary flow is between the vessel and on This to a of blood flow in the which is by of the of the coronary also a local effect of wall shear stress inducing local of of flow due to the presence of (Figure to determine be can be in material The will be with which the of the blood the These the for the which are to compute velocity and pressure from the equations for blood flow. this the or is by the of the arteries of Generally, a is in the in the velocity also Figure are This that a smaller are often used at the vessel while are in the central of the artery, the smaller in the velocity are also material Figure The to be by a to that will not in to the wall shear stress This is an for CFD also material CFD in coronary arteries in a boundary need to be for the the and the arterial wall. flow the velocity used is a a cardiac and time of the velocity at the is The for the can be in including a through the of the of or a widely blood flow velocity If flow are not can be are that the local of the artery to the a coronary artery the of coronary flow between the vessel and be be used to determine the flow These can be during clinical on computed tomography or If these are not can use a A pressure boundary at the can be to the flow a and boundary is at the arterial wall. recent interest in the coronary fluid has due to the information that can be from the of wall shear The nature of coronary flow can only be with or CFD to the boundary at both and are to capture the coronary flow material the between coronary flow in the and be boundary the velocity can be from or the velocity can be with a velocity the the of specialized coronary boundary is the change in coronary pressure in CFD are used boundary method is to the and to cardiac and coronary via an to and is in in material a of red blood cells blood and we on of the of the ability of to and under different flow conditions, and the effect on blood and impact on the wall shear stress has that at low shear and which in the of the blood (Figure is a to with shear and to The of from in an in local blood that to a at shear This fluid of to the shear is often to as a blood a CFD simplified the fluid of blood to a fluid a blood of it is to and in coronary flow CFD in red blood cells under blood cells at low shear in blood The process is as shear The solution in CFD with that determine the solution These are important and on many including the solution method and on the flow The appropriate of these and computational A key in the solution is CFD the Navier–Stokes equations are in an the in solving the equations and the solution is to be when of velocity and pressure are a also material provide reliable wall shear stress A of CFD that are and used in the is in used computational fluid provides that of appropriate and on to coronary used computational fluid provides that of appropriate and on to coronary can be from the computed wall shear stress Wall shear stress to to vessel the and or vessel the of to the boundary and be from Wall shear stress including include the shear and a recently called the wall shear a of these the is to material Figure of the often both and of the CFD to the in the is important to that both be on the of the and the of the data, in of and CFD can be in material from of both and coronary artery to need to be for blood flow to the are for of the local wall shear stress The arterial the blood is by or of and the appropriate size can only be by a with or at are blood be for by Each CFD be on and on the at and the solution Wall shear stress and its are to and appropriate of the depends on process is of blood flow in arteries of to flows in native the stent struts on the of the size of struts (Figure flow can be as the whereas the flow in the of the by vessel and can be called the The flow a is as a with wall shear stress on the and a at the of the on the flow and to the size of the stent and the flow associated with to be when CFD in of flow a stent and the and low wall shear stress the Wall shear stress in coronary arteries from to of a artery is and of the vessel with struts as the of is on the native vessel (Figure The is complex when the is are between the struts and the vessel wall. to capture the flow a a is material for the use of a and/or a a series of is an on the such as of stent different an when with flow as the size of are in the of magnitude as the struts of which can flow the of the the between and not be shear are the shear in the flow the is low and the impact of the blood in the of the flow is to be can be in a by them to and with flow. The of including blood in flow on this is an the presence of a the arterial wall is in arteries and but not in arteries 1 with When blood is as a fluid the solution is the as that for native arteries. is to the of the material for the and for the blood cells are in these are This is by the by as fluid or with the as an much and specialized when the is a vessel that of This of in has only to of vessels and are be in with the as in material When wall shear stress are the to the of information to be to can be reliable than per The of wall shear stress from CFD is when the time. an method to the such as the use of a which can also be in a of a is important material Figure flow are by vessel and flow by stent important in wall shear stress distribution in computational is a key to capture the flow the on the of are to the of a stent The effect of blood be by blood models. of blood are to the effect of but such computational and in studies that wall shear stress is a of endothelial function and the development of the major clinical interest in wall shear stress from its ability to at for or stent this complex clinical CFD studies to the of in and in human are from or This clinical and that be to CFD clinical in the material that the clinical studies in native arteries material and arteries material A of studies has wall shear stress in to coronary in native coronary arteries. CFD studies associated low wall shear stress with of and increased and in and vessel also wall shear stress with of and in to of and The of both with low and wall shear stress of and CFD studies that low wall shear stress is with a of with with and The wall shear stress in to clinical an of that low wall shear stress to to coronary during the of most of these = in treated for during coronary the of the of clinical low to with wall shear stress. has to with clinical A recent CFD of from the to of in the wall shear stress in with leading to major with that not during of clinical The that the presence of low wall shear stress associated with the development of the presence of such as smaller area, or with low wall shear stress a of to with and low wall shear stress in with or wall shear stress of These that low wall shear stress is important for and that low wall shear stress the to at for clinical the to point that not with low wall shear stress and that it which will to clinical The role of wall shear stress is also interest in recent CFD studies of a between in wall shear stress and the of CFD of a cannot as of these studies that wall shear stress of to A CFD also that wall shear stress an in The of increased at both of wall shear stress with the at the of wall shear stress The the of in and Computational with coronary and between 1 and the development of and that the non-invasive assessment including wall shear stress the of that that the wall shear stress of than that of These recently in a of the in which it that wall shear stress in the of a to the of to wall shear stress with on will be wall shear stress is to be used for of The most and important is the need for clinical CFD studies clinical with wall shear stress as it is does not with or to of atherosclerotic will also be The use of and multiple provide information fluid to vascular also arterial through and the of of CFD include use of flow conditions, of and or fluid in and of are also to the clinical of these with it is that clinical CFD will as of many and in clinical the also the of the process for for by the The development and of wall shear stress the regulatory process as clinical use of CFD to wall shear to use this be with the appropriate If can be include a of and/or or any of other in this is but to be Given the but associated with and has to studies to non-invasive on CFD be to the of low and wall shear stress associated with of and by clinical but the and studies are wall shear stress has associated with and High wall shear stress has associated with of coronary stenosis by through the of or by flow and a role in the and flow The advent of blood flow has in local of to healing and such as and the that a for the wall shear stress A in area, at the of the treated the flow and has associated with of low wall shear stress. at the of the a in or shear The clinical of this of shear stress has not studies low wall shear stress to stent wall shear stress vascular and which to has to be associated with and and also wall shear stress with of wall shear stress at the and low wall shear stress at the of the of a to impact wall shear stress and arterial from the vessel wall flow affecting at the the stent a vessel wall and blood a role as a for stent of the for CFD from to the impact of stent and in The wall shear stress distribution to the different of the stent or at the of the of to wall shear stress the of the wall shear stress with of and of the low wall shear stress with of which to and stent in an endothelium by The magnitude of the blood flow has to be on the and of the A wall shear stress for on has in of = the low wall shear stress stent can be a of the wall shear stress on vessel wall the stent structure and wall shear stress vessel wall used in the This that wall shear stress on a can as a in of stent and that from and with are associated with clinical as to stent the advent of with reduced has the of and and and reduced blood flow the in clinical cannot be to the but to a of and stent The of CFD has to the impact of coronary on blood flow and on arterial healing the the and computational of coronary as a to in the The of wall shear stress with arterial and CFD to clinical The of technology and of and the not only to stent but also to stent and tomography with of can be The with CFD for wall shear stress assessment in to stent be in the clinical studies the of the of CFD and wall shear stress are A of clinical studies are to the and effects of wall shear stress on These include the and the has to be to wall shear stress. wall shear stress associated with low wall shear stress does not with low wall shear stress and to healing with of wall shear stress. There is an between wall shear stress and the of in both and Wall shear stress endothelial vascular remodelling, and arterial healing Since wall shear stress cannot be measured in human coronary arteries, we solve the Navier–Stokes equations the motion of a The of CFD are by the quality of the input data, the geometrical of the coronary artery this we reviewed the methodologies to obtain reproducible and reliable wall shear stress in methodologies or with intravascular and in to simulate wall shear stress in both native and coronary arteries. CFD is in clinical applications, to compute pressure drop and determine FFR. The of wall shear stress with and can wall shear stress clinical we can the impact of the in of the and and the of on the local forces with these from in arteries, we also of wall shear stress in native arteries. for wall shear stress maps of the coronary much is for these maps to the in and use these maps to location of and we that clinical is to the of wall shear stress in and we that with in and computational CFD will be as of the major and in clinical of from from other from from the and from and from and from from from the from during the of the from from from from during the of the from from of the has a a Computational and for from the
逐年被引趋势
关键指标
同类平均 = 1
同领域 · 同年份 · 同类型
Google Scholar 与 OpenAlex 的被引统计范围不同,数值存在差异属正常。
AI 辅助阅读
依据:摘要
可就本文提问;依据不足时会说明。
学术脉络
学科主题
生物医学Coronary Interventions and Diagnostics
Elasticity and Material Modeling · Cardiac Imaging and Diagnostics
参考文献 149
此处列出前 3 条
引用本文 353
按被引量排序,此处列出前 3 条