A Response to “Reanalysis Validates Soil Health Indicator Sensitivity and Correlation with Long‐term Crop Yields”
Wayne R. Roper, Deanna L. Osmond, Joshua L. Heitman
University of Connecticut North Carolina State University
阅读操作
确认中在文库中上传 PDF 后可生成中文音频讲解。
摘要与影响
We published data showing that current soil health indicator (SHI) assessments do not consistently detect differences in a range of soil management practices implemented in North Carolina soils. Van Es and Karlen reanalyzed our data and asserted that it validates SHI correlation to crop yields and sensitivity to management as measured by the Comprehensive Assessment of Soil Health (CASH). We respond to van Es and Karlen with a more representative analysis of our data showing that individual SHI measurements are not predictive of crop yield from the 30‐yr North Carolina agronomic trial. Regressions for aggregate stability ( r 2 = 0.07) and P ( r 2 = 0.18) show that neither SHI sufficiently predicts corn yield for this dataset and show no obvious pattern based on tillage intensity. Relationships between corn ( Zea mays L.) yield and most biological SHI had r 2 ≤ 0.18, with only soil protein being moderately predictive of corn yield ( r 2 = 0.45). The CASH index to assess overall soil health by integrating physical, chemical, and biological SHI measurements into a single value of soil health is also not predictive of corn yield in the trial ( r 2 = 0.12). It is possible that current sampling and analytical procedures for assessing soil health do not consistently detect differences in productivity from soils with regional differences in land and ecological resources. We believe that calibrating SHI assessments to quantifiable agroecological outcomes instead of statistical rankings will reduce bias across regions and create a more inclusive framework for quantifying soil health.
逐年被引趋势
关键指标
同类平均 = 1
同领域 · 同年份 · 同类型
Google Scholar 与 OpenAlex 的被引统计范围不同,数值存在差异属正常。
AI 辅助阅读
依据:摘要
可就本文提问;依据不足时会说明。
学术脉络
学科主题
生物医学Soil Management and Crop Yield
Sustainable Agricultural Systems Analysis · Soil Science and Environmental Management