A Critical Review of Constitutive Models Applied to Ice-Crushing Simulations

In marine engineering, understanding the compressive behaviour of ice is crucial for accurately modelling ice loads on ships and offshore structures in ice-prone waters. Over the past few decades, numerous studies have focused on numerically simulating the ice-crushing process using various material models. A significant source of contention among these models lies in the representation of ice strength envelopes and their evolution with pressure and strain rate. Moreover, there is ongoing debate regarding whether plasticity or viscoelasticity more effectively captures the rheology of ice. Additionally, various flow rules have been implemented in plasticity models and different damage models have been used in viscoelasticity models, all of which play a critical role in simulating ice loads. This critical review aims to shed light on the reasons behind these disagreements and to evaluate the advantages and limitations of the most commonly used models, based on established theories in ice mechanics and empirical evidence.